Abstract
A guide to the technical shape of a video file: how still frames become motion, how many pixels make a frame, the shape of the frame, how many frames make a second, how the picture is scanned and broadcast, and how much data and colour is stored. It ends with codecs and the difference between IPB and ALL-I compression, all tied to choices made for the short film One Cloud.Keywords: video formats, persistence of vision, phi phenomenon, resolution, 4K, aspect ratio, 2.39:1, 16:9, frame rate, slow motion, interlaced, progressive, PAL, NTSC, bitrate, chroma subsampling, 4:2:2, codec, H.264, H.265, ALL-I, IPB
How do still frames become moving pictures?
Short answer. A film is a fast sequence of still frames. Shown quickly enough, the brain reads them as continuous motion.
The illusion of motion
Moving pictures work because the brain joins a rapid series of still images into one movement. The older idea of persistence of vision, an image lingering on the eye, is now joined by the phi phenomenon, described by Max Wertheimer in 1912, which explains seen motion between still images.
- In 1878 Eadweard Muybridge photographed a galloping horse with a row of cameras, proving all four hooves leave the ground.
- A flip book shows the same idea by hand.
- About 12 images a second begin to read as motion; cinema settled on 24.
Draw a simple flip book of a ball bouncing. It teaches frame rate and timing faster than any lecture.
- Draw 12 frames of a ball bouncing on paper.
- Flip them fast.
- Remove every second frame and flip again.
Time-lapse and stop motion
Time-lapse records frames at long, equal intervals and plays them fast, so slow events such as clouds or crowds speed up. Stop motion moves an object a little between each frame, so it seems to move on its own.
| Time-lapse | Stop motion | |
|---|---|---|
| What moves | The world, by itself | Objects moved by hand |
| Time between frames | Equal | Uneven, as long as needed |
| Typical use | Clouds, cities, plants, construction | Animation, product films |
| Tools | Intervalometer, tripod | Tripod, fixed lights, puppets |
For time-lapse, lock exposure and white balance in manual, or the frames will flicker.
- Shoot 10 minutes of clouds, one frame every 2 seconds.
- Play it back at 24 fps.
- Count how long it lasts on screen.
One Cloud opens on a time-lapse of real clouds passing over the floating city, a hint of the weather the city has lost.
Stop motion features take weeks per minute: each second of screen time needs 12 to 24 hand moved frames.
What are resolution and aspect ratio?
Short answer. Resolution is how many pixels make the frame; aspect ratio is the shape of the frame, width to height.
Resolution
A pixel is the smallest dot of a digital image. Resolution is the number of pixels across and down, for example 1920 by 1080. K stands for thousand, roughly the number of pixels across.
| Name | Pixels | Note |
|---|---|---|
| HD (720p) | 1280 x 720 | Web, older TV |
| Full HD (1080p) | 1920 x 1080 | Most web and TV |
| QHD (1440p) | 2560 x 1440 | Monitors, phones |
| UHD 4K | 3840 x 2160 | 4K TV, streaming |
| DCI 4K | 4096 x 2160 | Digital cinema |
| 8K UHD | 7680 x 4320 | High end capture |
Shoot higher than you deliver. A 4K image lets you reframe or stabilise a Full HD edit.
- Check the resolution menu of your camera.
- Shoot one shot in Full HD and one in 4K.
- Crop both to the same framing and compare sharpness.
Aspect ratio
Aspect ratio is the width of the frame compared with its height, written as width to height, such as 16:9 or 2.39:1. It does not depend on screen size; a 4:3 picture is 4:3 on a phone and on a cinema screen.
- 4:3 (1.33:1): early cinema and television; now chosen for an intimate or period feel.
- 16:9 (1.78:1): television and web.
- 1.85:1: standard cinema widescreen.
- 2:1: Univisium, proposed by Vittorio Storaro, now common in streaming.
- 2.39:1: anamorphic scope, for wide story worlds and landscapes.
- 9:16: vertical video for phones and social media.
Choose the ratio for the story world. Wide ratios hold landscapes and groups; narrow ratios press in on a face.
- Frame the same scene in 4:3, 16:9 and 2.39:1 with tape on your screen.
- Note what each ratio leaves out.
- Choose one for your film and write why.
One Cloud is framed 2.39:1 so the floating city and the sea stay in frame even in close-ups; a 9:16 trailer is cut for phones.
Some films change aspect ratio between time periods, so the audience feels the jump without a title card.
What frame rate and scan should you choose?
Short answer. Frame rate is how many frames are captured or shown each second. Capture faster than you play back for slow motion. Progressive scan suits almost all modern work.
Frame rate and slow motion
Frame rate, in frames per second or fps, is how often the camera records a frame. Capture frame rate is set before shooting; project or timeline frame rate is set in the edit. The relation between them gives normal, slow or fast motion.
| Capture | Playback | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 24 | 24 | Normal motion |
| 48 or 50 | 24 or 25 | Half speed slow motion |
| 120 | 24 | Five times slower |
| 12 | 24 | Double speed, fast motion |
- Cinema uses 24 fps; Indian broadcast uses 25; NTSC regions use 30.
- Higher frame rates look smoother and make bigger files.
Decide slow motion before you shoot. You cannot slow 24 fps footage smoothly in the edit.
- Shoot water pouring at 24 fps and at 100 or 120 fps.
- Play both on a 24 fps timeline.
- Note the shutter you used for each.
Interlaced, progressive and broadcast systems
Interlaced video, marked i, draws odd lines then even lines; progressive video, marked p, draws every line at once. Broadcast systems such as PAL and NTSC fixed the line count and frame rate for analogue television.
| System | Lines | Frame rate | Where |
|---|---|---|---|
| PAL | 625 | 25 | India, UK, most of Europe, Asia and Australia |
| NTSC | 525 | 29.97 | North America, Japan, South Korea |
| SECAM | 625 | 25 | France, former Soviet countries, parts of Africa |
Shoot progressive. Interlaced footage causes comb lines on movement when shown on modern screens.
- Find 1080i and 1080p in an old camera or TV menu.
- Pan quickly in each mode.
- Look for comb lines on edges.
One Cloud is shot 24p, with the paper boat insert at 50p for a gentle half speed float.
Some action features shoot at 48 or 120 fps for very smooth motion; many viewers find it looks too real, like television.
What are bitrate and chroma subsampling?
Short answer. Bitrate is how much data is stored each second; chroma subsampling is how much colour detail is kept. Both decide quality and file size.
Bitrate
Bitrate is the amount of data written per second of video, in megabits per second, Mbps. Higher bitrate means less compression, better quality and larger files. Bitrate is not resolution: a 4K file at a low bitrate can look worse than a well recorded Full HD file.
- Choose the highest bitrate your cards and storage can hold.
- Fast movement, rain, leaves and grain need more data.
- Check that your memory card speed class matches the bitrate; see memory cards.
Work out storage before the shoot: bitrate in Mbps x seconds ÷ 8 gives megabytes.
- Find the bitrate of each recording mode on your camera.
- Work out how many minutes fit on a 128 GB card.
- Plan cards for a full day.
Chroma subsampling
Every pixel records brightness, called luma, and colour, called chroma. Chroma subsampling keeps all the brightness but lets groups of pixels share colour, written as J:a:b, such as 4:2:2. The eye notices brightness detail more than colour detail, so this saves data with little visible loss.
- 4:4:4: full colour, largest files.
- 4:2:2: half the colour detail across, used for professional and green screen work.
- 4:2:0: a quarter of the colour detail, used by most consumer cameras and streaming.
- J is the width of the sample block, usually 4; a is colour samples in the first row; b is colour samples in the second row.
- Use 4:2:2 or better for green screen, heavy grading and visual effects.
- Video stores luma Y and two colour difference signals, often written YCbCr.
If your camera offers 10-bit 4:2:2, use it for footage you will grade. The difference shows in skies and skin.
- Find the colour sampling of your camera modes.
- Shoot a green screen in 4:2:0 and 4:2:2 if possible.
- Compare the edge of the hair after keying.
One Cloud records 10-bit 4:2:2 so the teal sea and orange sunrise can be pushed in the grade without banding.
Visual effects shots are often delivered as 4:4:4 files so every keyed edge stays clean.
Which codec should you record and edit with?
Short answer. A codec compresses video for storage and decompresses it for playback. H.264 and H.265 save space; ALL-I and editing codecs are easier to cut and grade.
Codecs and containers
A codec, coder and decoder, compresses video data for storage and expands it for playback. The container or wrapper, such as MP4 or MOV, holds the video, audio and timecode together.
| Codec | Also called | Good for |
|---|---|---|
| H.264 | AVC, MPEG-4 Part 10 | Web delivery, small files, wide support |
| H.265 | HEVC | About 25 to 50 percent smaller than H.264 at the same quality; up to 8K |
| XAVC S | Sony camera format | H.264 or H.265 in MP4 with uncompressed audio |
| AVCHD | Sony and Panasonic, 2006 | Older HD camcorders |
| ProRes, DNxHR | Editing codecs | Smooth editing and grading, large files |
Record in the best codec your camera offers, edit with proxies if the computer struggles, and export H.264 or H.265 for the web.
- Check which codecs your camera records.
- Make proxy files of one clip in your editor.
- Compare playback smoothness.
IPB and ALL-I compression
IPB, or long GOP, stores a complete I-frame and then P and B frames that record only what changes. ALL-I stores every frame complete. ALL-I files are bigger but easier for a computer to edit and usually hold quality better.
- I-frame: a full picture, the key frame.
- P-frame: predicted from earlier frames.
- B-frame: predicted from frames before and after.
- In an interview, IPB stores the still background once and records only the moving speaker.
Use ALL-I for fast action and heavy grading; IPB is fine for interviews and long events where card space matters.
- Record 30 seconds in IPB and in ALL-I if your camera allows.
- Compare file sizes.
- Scrub both in your editor.
One Cloud records H.265 ALL-I 4:2:2 in camera, edits on proxies, and is delivered as H.264 for festivals online.
Features often record raw or ProRes, and the edit team works on lighter proxies until the final conform.
Questions beginners ask
24 fps is the cinema standard and gives the familiar film look. In India, 25 fps matches broadcast. Shoot 50, 100 or 120 fps only for planned slow motion.
16:9 for television and web, 1.85:1 or 2.39:1 for a cinema look, and 9:16 for phone first social video. Choose for the story world, then frame for it from the start.
Not always. A low bitrate 4K file can look worse than a well recorded Full HD file. 4K helps when you need to crop, stabilise or deliver in 4K.
It is a chroma subsampling pattern that keeps all brightness detail and half the colour detail across the frame. It grades and keys better than 4:2:0.
H.265 makes files about 25 to 50 percent smaller at the same quality but needs more computer power to edit. H.264 is easier and more widely supported.
ALL-I stores every frame complete, giving bigger files that edit easily. IPB stores key frames and predicts the rest, giving smaller files.
References
- Ascher, S. and Pincus, E. (2012) The filmmaker’s handbook: A comprehensive guide for the digital age. 4th edn. New York: Plume.
- Brown, B. (2016) Cinematography: Theory and practice. 3rd edn. New York: Routledge.
- Poynton, C. (2012) Digital video and HD: Algorithms and interfaces. 2nd edn. Waltham: Morgan Kaufmann.
- Wertheimer, M. (1912) ‘Experimentelle Studien über das Sehen von Bewegung’, Zeitschrift für Psychologie, 61, pp. 161 to 265.
Further reading
Make this your craft at Creative Hut Academy
Creative Hut Academy in Mattakkara, Kottayam, Keralam teaches photography, cinematography, editing, sound and AI filmmaking in one-year residential diplomas. Students come from across India.
Want to talk? Message us on WhatsApp, or ask Cham, our AI mentor, a study doubt.